This is an ever growing list of shops I highly recommend. Some are online and some are physical shops.
Blue Velvet Vintage (online)
Unique Vintage (online)
Vintage Treasures by Grandmalay (online)
Blast from the Past-Vineland, NJ. Fantastic antique shop and the women that own and run the store are very nice. You will not leave empty handed.
Twice Loved Treasures- Vineland, NJ. I've gotten many dresses and blouses from this shop.
Glassboro Thrift Village- Glassboro, NJ. Fantastic selection of jewelry, glassware, knick knacks. Plenty of holiday decorations and I've gotten some neat vintage clothes here too.
Ternay's Shop in the Woods- Williamstown, NJ. A cute little antique shop nestled in the woods. Fantastic selection, they even have some vintage perfumes.
Wacker's Trading Post-Pitman NJ. Beautiful selection of vintage and antique furniture and all sorts of other things from pianos to glassware.
Sweet n Sour Vintage (online)-Top quality vintage shop run by the lovely Natalie! There are so many party dresses to covet.